I voted for Neil. First of all, Neil is the much better name. And even though he's a member of the inferior incarnation of Suede, his band is still light years better than Alex James'. When Neil is onstage playing Animal Nitrate or To The Birds or My Dark Star, he probably thinks to himself, "I wish I was in this band when Butler was in it." I like middle-aged Neil's posture and wrinkles and hair, and his tweed blazer fashion sense when he's not wearing his black leather "Suedegear." I'm disappointed that the photos of Neil you provided are all from the young and pretty era. He looks gentle and professorial now. But the kiss of death for Alex James is that he owns a dairy. F*ck him.