The Smiths Survival Game (The Smiths)

[Anaesthesine]

Reel Around The Fountain - 18 (+)
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 22 (-)
Still Ill - 20
Hand in Glove - 22
What Difference Does It Make? - 19

 

[Soil Falling Over]

Reel Around The Fountain - 18
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 22
Still Ill - 21 (+)
Hand in Glove - 21 (-)
What Difference Does It Make? - 19

 

[Neader]

Reel Around The Fountain - 18
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 21 (-1)
Still Ill - 22 (+)
Hand in Glove - 21 (-)
What Difference Does It Make? - 19

 

[Oh my god. it's Robby!]

Reel Around The Fountain - 18
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 22 (+1)
Still Ill - 21 (-1)
Hand in Glove - 21 (-)
What Difference Does It Make? - 19
-i am only still playing cuz ppl attack pgmg

 

[Girl-with-the-Thorn]

Reel Around The Fountain - 19 (+1)
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 22
Still Ill - 21
Hand in Glove - 20 (-1)
What Difference Does It Make? - 19

RATF needs more love.

 

[Qvist]

No, it needs less - overrated as it has always been.

Reel Around The Fountain - 18 (-1)
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 22
Still Ill - 21
Hand in Glove - 21 (+1)
What Difference Does It Make? - 19

 

[Will_Never_Marry]

Reel Around The Fountain - 18
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 21 (-)
Still Ill - 22 (+)
Hand in Glove - 21
What Difference Does It Make? - 19

Still Ill has to win.

 

[Girl-with-the-Thorn]

No, it needs less - overrated as it has always been.

Reel Around The Fountain - 18 (-1)

Really? I think it's wonderful, but different strokes I guess. I've always thought 'Hand in Glove' was terribly overrated (hence my constantly subtracting from it on this thread ) and that 'Still Ill' would have been a much better choice for the first single... but I digress. That's for another thread at another time.

 

[Patrick!]

Reel Around The Fountain - 18
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 22 (+)
Still Ill - 22
Hand in Glove - 21
What Difference Does It Make? - 18 (-)

 

[nightingale+therose]

Reel Around The Fountain - 19 (+)
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 21 (-)
Still Ill - 22
Hand in Glove - 21
What Difference Does It Make? - 18

 

[Will_Never_Marry]

Reel Around The Fountain - 19
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 20 (-)
Still Ill - 23 (+)
Hand in Glove - 21
What Difference Does It Make? - 18

 

[bored]

Reel Around The Fountain - 20 (+)
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 20
Still Ill - 22 (-)
Hand in Glove - 21
What Difference Does It Make? - 18

Anyone get the feeling none of these song will ever be voted off?

 

[CrystalGeezer]

Reel Around The Fountain - 19 (-)
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 21 (+)
Still Ill - 22
Hand in Glove - 21
What Difference Does It Make? - 18

 

[mammaof3]

Reel Around The Fountain - 19
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 20 (-)
Still Ill - 22
Hand in Glove - 22 (+)
What Difference Does It Make? - 18

 

[Oh my god. it's Robby!]

Reel Around The Fountain - 19
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 21 (+)
Still Ill - 21 (-)
Hand in Glove - 22
What Difference Does It Make? - 18

 

[Qvist]

Really? I think it's wonderful, but different strokes I guess. I've always thought 'Hand in Glove' was terribly overrated (hence my constantly subtracting from it on this thread ) and that 'Still Ill' would have been a much better choice for the first single... but I digress. That's for another thread at another time.

That's the way it goes.

Reel Around The Fountain - 18 (-1)
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 21
Still Ill - 21
Hand in Glove - 22
What Difference Does It Make? - 19 (+1)

 

[Will_Never_Marry]

Reel Around The Fountain - 18
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 21
Still Ill - 22 (+)
Hand in Glove - 21 (-)
What Difference Does It Make? - 19

 

[bored]

Reel Around The Fountain - 19 (+)
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 21
Still Ill - 21 (-)
Hand in Glove - 21
What Difference Does It Make? - 19

 

[Oh my god. it's Robby!]

Reel Around The Fountain - 19
Pretty Girls Make Graves - 22 (+)
Still Ill - 20 (-)
Hand in Glove - 21
What Difference Does It Make? - 19

-as I have said before, all these songs are great and I shall listen to all 5 of them now

 

[Anaesthesine]

RATF needs more love.

I know. I've been giving RATF a + 1 every time, which has been efficeintly countered by Qvist's - 1.

This whole exercise is a bit like meditation at this point.