Hi Anaesthesine,
I'm an on-again/off-again lurker to the site, and I have to say that your posts always intrigue me. I find you fascinating, really.
But, if I may, I would like to make a rebuttal to your rebuttal.
You've made this argument before, and with all due respect, I
100% disagree with it. I don't think he's undermining anything.
To many people, around the world, Morrissey-
the 2013 version- is still incredibly beloved. And relevant. Much more than any other pop star I can think of. In fact, the more hate he incurs, whether it is on this site, Twitter, or the general hipster music press, in many ways, he becomes
more relatable.
It is my opinion,having just come back from a 2-year long job assignment in Argentina (I'm currently crashing on the couch of a fellow fan in the States, btw), this is why many foreign fans resonate with Morrissey in a way that many of the more jaded and ironic USA and UK fans don't anymore.
I have a friend in South America,in Chile, who is working
three jobs to pay off debts she incurred seeing him all over the continent when he toured South America last spring. She's more than willing to do it again. I know for her, and I would gather many of her fellow fans there and elsewhere, if Morrissey
truly had tarnished his legacy to any large degree, she wouldn't be sacrificing so much to see him again. She sees Morrissey as a source of honesty, of strength, of sensitivity and passion, of beauty, and yes, as a victim of relentless bullying for daring to be different or eccentric. Does she (or I) think "People Are the Same Everywhere" is a great song? No, we don't. But we really don't care too much about that, either. One or two or even ten crappy songs don't undo a legacy of amazing ones. And I'm optimistic there are more to come.
And 2013 Morrissey still makes beautiful, witty, endearing statements, and shows lots of heart and kindess...but those don't garner endless discussions on how he's deliberately destroying his career.
(And, there are many South American based Morrissey fan pages, where they read about the up-to-the-minute happenings of Morrissey 2013, but those sites are more like AYNIM than this site. In that they tend to respectful and reverential to Morrissey.)
I think that's part of the big disconnect between fans who are more ironic about their fandom for Morrissey and fans who are extremely sincere and earnest in it. Those fans who
love him, not just like him. We don't see that much of a difference between Morrissey of 1983 and Morrissey of 2013. Yes, age and perspective, of course, but his heart and essence are the same to me-and many of his fans worldwide. It's not just a love of nostalgia that drives these international tours. And I truly believe he hasn't destroyed any of his legacy or relevance-deliberately or otherwise. I genuinely don't.